The Best Bourbon? It Depends.

One of the most common questions I get as a bourbon enthusiast is, “What’s the best bourbon?” To me, that’s nearly impossible to answer—it all depends on the mood, setting, and how I plan to enjoy it. If I’m relaxing at home, just me or with my wife, a few bottles stand out. Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel is a go-to, offering a wide range of profiles that never disappoint. Maker’s Mark 46 Cask Strength and Private Select bottles are also favorites, providing versatility whether I’m sipping neat, on the rocks, or in a cocktail. For something bolder, Old Forester 1920 delivers a higher proof that I like to take my time with.

Beyond these staples, I also enjoy experimenting with new bottles, letting them open up over time to see how they evolve in the glass. But when I have guests over, that’s when I like to share some of the best bottles in my collection—bourbon is meant to be enjoyed with others. If you’re looking for a solid bottle to pick up today, you can’t go wrong with any of these choices. They hit that sweet spot of quality and price, typically ranging from $50 to $80, and provide an excellent drinking experience whether you’re enjoying a quiet night in or sharing a pour with friends.